Books Are for Talking Too!, fourth edition

by Jane L. Gebershttps://soundingyourbest.com/

ElaGrades Pre-K–5

About This Curriculum

A research-based resource for promoting early literacy and oral communication skills through low-text picture books, featuring over 250 children's book entries with detailed methods for targeting specific skills.

What makes it unique: The only comprehensive guide that combines speech-language pathology expertise with children's literature, providing specific therapeutic activities for over 250 carefully selected picture books

Books Are for Talking Too!: Speech-Language Resource for Picture Books

Books Are for Talking Too!, fourth edition is a 551-page resource guide written by speech-language pathologist Jane L. Gebers that provides detailed methods for using over 250 low-text picture books to develop oral communication and early literacy skills. The curriculum is designed primarily for professional educators, speech therapists, and service providers working with children from Pre-K through grade 5.

Best for

Speech-language pathologists, special education teachers, and intervention specialists working with students who need targeted oral communication and early literacy skill development in Pre-K through elementary grades

Evaluation Criteria

5 strengths · 3 concerns · 1 insufficient evidence

Teacher TrainingStrength

The resource provides substantial professional guidance with detailed methodological sections and background information. Each section begins with comprehensive 'how to' information for implementing activities effectively.

Written 'primarily for professional educators and service providers' with detailed methods sections and 'how to information at the beginning of each section'

Direct InstructionStrength

The curriculum provides explicit, structured instruction with detailed methods for each book. The 'Method' sections offer specific teaching suggestions and step-by-step activities for targeted skill development.

Each book includes a 'Method' section with 'specific suggestions for teaching the targeted skills' and 'series of steps' that build systematically

Systematic PhonicsStrength

The curriculum includes systematic phonological awareness instruction through dedicated activities and games. Section 2 specifically addresses phonological awareness with beginning and advanced levels, though it's designed as supplementary rather than primary phonics instruction.

Section 2 provides 'activities like clapping out syllables' and 'activities to teach several different skills' with 'many activities mirroring those used within good beginning phonics programs'

Vocabulary BuildingStrength

Vocabulary development is explicitly addressed as a target skill category with specific methods for expanding word knowledge. The curriculum provides structured approaches to vocabulary instruction through picture books.

Vocabulary is listed as one of the 'Target Skills' categories, with specific methods like 'brainstorm other words that can be used as metaphors or similes' and expanding sentence constructions

Whole Books Vs ExcerptsStrength

The curriculum centers on complete picture books rather than excerpts or passages. Each of the 250+ recommended books receives detailed treatment with full story synopses and comprehensive skill-building activities.

The resource recommends 'well over 100 books' in each major section, with detailed catalogs providing 1-4 pages of information per complete picture book

Knowledge RichConcern

The curriculum has limited focus on systematic domain knowledge building, instead prioritizing speech and language skill development. While books are indexed by topics like 'Cities; New York City; Culture and history, Hispanic,' the primary emphasis is therapeutic rather than knowledge-rich.

Topics are listed for indexing purposes but the focus is on 'Target Skills' like articulation, grammar, and syntax rather than building coherent domain knowledge

Text ComplexityConcern

The curriculum deliberately uses low-text picture books rather than complex texts. While this serves the therapeutic purpose, it may not provide sufficient text complexity progression for grade-level reading development.

Recommends 'picture books' with 'minimal text' that 'can be used in relatively brief sessions' for targeted therapy goals

Writing InstructionConcern

Writing instruction is not a primary focus of this curriculum. The resource emphasizes oral communication and listening skills rather than systematic writing development.

No mention of writing instruction in the detailed review descriptions; focus is on 'oral communication and literacy skills' and 'speech therapy'

Retrieval PracticeInsufficient Evidence

Limited evidence of systematic retrieval practice or spaced review components. The curriculum focuses more on initial skill introduction than long-term retention strategies.

No specific mention of retrieval practice, spaced review, or systematic review components in the detailed descriptions

Review Sources

web_search

SLP Storytellers

cathyduffy

Cathy Duffy

Key Facts
GradesGrades Pre-K–5
SubjectEla
PedagogyTraditional
Faith-BasedNo
FormatPhysical
Pricing$61.95 at Amazon.com

Looking for something different?

If none of these options feel right, explore a non-traditional approach. Pallas Center offers a unique curriculum, or design your own with Palladay.

Data sources: cathyduffy