Carnegie Learning High School Math Solution Integrated

by Carnegie Learning

MathGrades 9–12

About This Curriculum

A research-proven, blended learning solution for grades 6-12 that combines MATHbook collaborative activities with MATHia AI-powered personalized coaching, aligned to state standards with integrated digital and print materials for high school integrated mathematics curriculum.

What makes it unique: Research-backed blended approach combining collaborative MATHbook lessons with MATHia adaptive tutoring software, with extensive facilitation notes and real-time data insights to support differentiated instruction

Carnegie Learning High School Math Solution Integrated: Blended AI-Powered Curriculum

Carnegie Learning High School Math Solution Integrated is a blended learning math curriculum for grades 9-12 that combines collaborative MATHbook activities with MATHia AI-powered personalized coaching. The curriculum uses an "Engage-Develop-Practice" structure and integrates digital and print materials aligned to state standards.

Best for

High schools seeking a blended learning math curriculum with AI-powered personalization, particularly those with technology resources and teachers comfortable with traditional instructional approaches.

Evaluation Criteria

3 strengths · 1 concern · 3 neutral · 2 insufficient evidence

Direct InstructionStrength

The curriculum follows a traditional teacher-centered approach with an "Engage-Develop-Practice" structure that aligns with direct instruction principles. The I do, We do, You do format supports explicit teaching.

New Mexico review described the approach as 'somewhat traditional, featuring an Engage-Develop-Practice teacher-centered lesson structure (I do, We do, You do)'

Sequencing ApproachStrength

The curriculum demonstrates strong focus and coherence in its sequencing approach with integrated mathematics content. EdReports confirmed appropriate alignment to grade-level standards and focus on major mathematical work.

EdReports Gateway 1 (Focus & Coherence) received 'Meets Expectations' ratings for alignment to grade-level math standards and focus on major work of the grade

Conceptual Procedural BalanceStrength

The curriculum meets expectations for balancing conceptual understanding, procedural skill, and application according to EdReports Gateway 2 standards. However, New Mexico reviewers noted the approach can be somewhat traditional and dry.

EdReports gave Gateway 2 (Rigor & Mathematical Practices) a 'Meets Expectations' rating, indicating appropriate balance of conceptual understanding, procedural skill, and application

Word ProblemsConcern

While EdReports confirmed the curriculum meets expectations for application, New Mexico reviewers noted limited opportunities for students to present strategies and defend reasoning in problem-solving contexts.

New Mexico review noted 'students have limited opportunities to present strategies, defend reasoning, and critique peer thinking'

Worked ExamplesNeutral

The curriculum includes detailed facilitation notes and lesson planning guidance in the Teacher's Edition. The traditional "I do, We do, You do" structure suggests inclusion of teacher modeling and worked examples.

New Mexico review noted the 'Engage-Develop-Practice' teacher-centered lesson structure and extensive 'Facilitation Notes' with detailed lesson planning guidance

Teacher TrainingNeutral

The curriculum includes extensive teacher support materials with detailed facilitation notes and differentiation strategies. However, broader teacher learning resources focused on standards understanding are limited.

New Mexico review highlighted 'extensive Facilitation Notes with detailed lesson planning guidance, suggestions for addressing common misunderstandings, and differentiation strategies' as a strength, but noted 'limited teacher learning resources focused on standards understanding'

Assessment DiagnosticNeutral

The MATHia AI component and PDF customization features suggest diagnostic capabilities, and EdReports confirmed the curriculum meets usability expectations including assessment. However, specific diagnostic assessment details are not provided.

EdReports Gateway 3 (Usability) including assessment received 'Meets Expectations' and the curriculum provides 'PDF versions of materials that can be customized for individual learners'

Retrieval PracticeInsufficient Evidence

The MATHia AI-powered personalized coaching component likely provides spaced practice opportunities, though specific details about retrieval practice and cumulative review are not detailed in the available reviews.

The curriculum includes 'MATHia AI-powered personalized coaching' which suggests adaptive practice opportunities

Visual RepresentationsInsufficient Evidence

The curriculum encourages use of graphing technology and calculators for advanced topics like regressions and binomial distributions. However, specific evidence about visual models and manipulatives is limited in the reviews.

New Mexico review noted that Integrated Math III encourages graphing technology and calculators for regressions and binomial distributions

Review Sources

edreports

EdReports Panel

Gateway 1 Alignment:Meets Expectations
Gateway 2 Alignment:Meets Expectations
Gateway 3 Alignment:Meets Expectations
web_search

New Mexico Department of Education Review Team

Key Facts
GradesGrades 9–12
SubjectMath
PedagogyBlended
Faith-BasedNo
FormatDigital + Physical
PricingApproximately $35/student/year for blended materials (textbook + software), with discounts available based on enrollment size and implementation duration

Looking for something different?

If none of these options feel right, explore a non-traditional approach. Pallas Center offers a unique curriculum, or design your own with Palladay.

Data sources: edreports, cathyduffy